Review: The Legend of Georgia McBride (Northlight Theatre)

| October 4, 2017

Nate Santana stars as Casey in The Legend of Georgia McBride, Northlight Theatre            

The Legend
  of Georgia McBride

Written by Matthew Lopez 
Northlight Theatre, 9501 Skokie Blvd. (map)
thru Oct 22  |  tix: $30-$81  |  more info
Check for half-price tickets   


Initially light fare, ‘Georgia’ ultimately raises a sequined fist to the sky


Jeff Kurysz, Nate Santana and Sean Blake star in Legend of Georgia McBride

Northlight Theatre presents
The Legend of Georgia McBride

Review by Catey Sullivan

For the first two thirds of Matthew LopezThe Legend of Georgia McBride, Northlight audiences are treated to a whacky, audience-pleasing comedy with all the depth of a coat of mascara.

The plot goes for guffaws by showing the whacky plight of a cis-gender straight guy trying to navigate in heels and a dress. Good-hearted good ol’ boy Casey (Nate Santana) is an Elvis Nate Santana and Sean Blake star as Casey and Miss Tracy in Legend of Georgia McBride, Northlight Theatreimpersonator, but when the local bar brings in a drag act and cancels his sparsely-attended impersonations of the King, the erst-while Elvis finds himself trying to lip synch to the likes of Edith Piaf and Shania Twain.

With a pregnant wife and a history of bounced rent checks, drag is a career of last resort for Casey. Under the patient tutelage of sassy-but-kind veteran drag mama Miss Tracy Mills (Sean Blake), Casey’s attempts to tuck and strut make for plenty of whacky antics. For a good while, it seems the comedy of Casey’s fish-out-of-water awkwardness is the sum total of Georgia McBride, and that the show is little more than a pleasant diversion.

But with the final third, Lopez steers The Legend of Georgia McBride straight into something else entirely. Casey’s antics as the drag queen Georgia McBride – and the treatment of drag as something silly whose main purpose is to make straights giggle – take a back seat as Miss Tracy and her co-star Rexy (Jeff Kurysz) show Casey that drag means more than smearing on some lipstick and prancing around in a dress.

“You have no idea what this means to me!” Casey exclaims when he feels Georgia is in danger of being upstaged. To which Rexy responds – with the stone-cold precision of a perfectly executed mic drop – “You have no idea what this means.”

 Sean Blake stars as Miss Tracy Mills in The Legend of Georgia McBride, Northlight Theatre Nate Santana stars as Casey in The Legend of Georgia McBride, Northlight TheatreNate Santana, Keith Kupferer and Jeff Kurysz star in Legend of Georgia McBride

Indeed, Casey does not. To him, drag is a way to pay the rent and make people chuckle. Miss Tracy and Rexy know better. Drag, they tell him, “is a raised fist in a sequined glove.” At Stonewall, it was the start of a revolution. It is a profound subversion of the gender binary that has long locked the world into ridiculously narrow way of viewing humanity. In the wigs and the sequins and paint and the foundation garments, it is an insurrection both cultural and historical. It’s entertainment, but it is not the toy Casey’s been playing with for fun and profit. It is also not the source of homophobic shame that has kept Casey from telling his girlfriend Jo (Leslie Ann Sheppard) that Elvis has left the building and the chanteuse Georgia McBride has taken his place.

Directed by Lauren Shouse, The Legend of Georgia McBride is initially lightweight, but ultimately raises that sequined fist to the sky in a manner that elevates the entire production.

A significant caveat: The drag on display in the show isn’t great. Professional drag queens can spend hours putting on their faces – the art of illusion is one of fastidious, laborious detail. At Northlight, Casey and Tracy and Rexy are in-and-out of drag in minutes. None of them would pass muster in any self-respecting drag show higher than the level of community theater. The wigs and the padding are terrible, as is their paint.  Granted, they’re in a backwater bar without proper dressing rooms and lighting, but still – their act leaves you longing for a bit more illusion.

A lesser problem lies with Miss Tracy’s almost magical ability to make money rain down on Cleo’s, the Panama City dive bar where Georgia McBride unfolds. Lopez’ plot rests on the premise that the Panama City area is home to legions of drag lovers, enough to turn the bar from desperate to flush in very short order. It’s a questionable premise to be sure, but not a deal-breaker. 

That said, Shouse’s ensemble is charming enough to make you forgive a host of sins. As Cleo’s owner Eddie, Keith Kupferer has a glint of the devil in his southern drawl, and gives the cheesiest lines (“clutch those pearls and watch those twirls!”) an earnestness that is hilarious. Moreover, the sight of Kupferer manning a bubble machine is perhaps a once-in-a-lifetime visual which probably shouldn’t be missed.  

Nate Santana and Sean Blake star as Casey and Miss Tracy in Legend of Georgia McBride Northlight TheatreLeslie Ann Sheppard (Jo) and Nate Santana (Casey) star in in The Legend of Georgia McBride, Northlight T

As Miss Tracy Mills, Blake’s long career as a dancer serves him well. When he launches into a medley of Streisand/Merman/Garland tunes, he’s got the moves to carry it off. Moreoever, Blake’s lip synching skills are not trifling. But Tracy is more than a performer. Blake’s delivery of a late-night heart-to-heart with the conflicted Casey captures the Tracy‘s out-of-drag queen persona. Blake makes the scene pop with a blend of weary wisdom, full-hearted compassion and acid-bath sarcasm.

Santana has you rooting for Casey from the start, even if he is the sort of boy who bounces rent checks by ordering pizzas he can’t afford. He’s a child, but an endearing one. As Casey’s wife Jo, Sheppard is the adult in the relationship and brings all the exasperation that being so entails. The love between the couple is evident, but it’s clear from the start that Casey is going to have to grow up in order for this marriage to survive.

As Rexy, Kurysz is all imperious attitude. Rexy’s a diva (“Grab a sweater. You’re going to need it in my shadow.”), but one with a heart of gold. Like Casey’s, her journey is predictable. But like Santana, Kurysz has the charm and verve to make it entertaining.

Double-cast as Casey and Jo’s landlord Jason, Kurysz has a passage about a New Orleans dalliance that the world at large would do well to heed. Jason, it seems, once fell in love with a transgender woman. He freaked out, and fled. “The heart wants what the heart wants,” Jason says, “I was just focused on the wrong organ.”

Rating: ★★★

The Legend of Georgia McBride continues through October 22nd at the North Shore Center for the Performing Arts, 9501 Skokie Blvd. (map), with performances Tuesdays 7:30pm, Wednesdays 1pm & 7:30pm, Thursdays 7:30pm, Fridays 8pm, Saturdays 2:30pm & 8pm, Sundays 2:30pm & 7pm.  Tickets are $30-$81 (students w/ ID: $15), and are available by phone (847-673-6300) or online through their website (check for availability of half-price tickets). More information at time: 1 hour 40 minutes, no intermission)

Nate Santana, Keith Kupferer, and Sean Blake star in Legend of Georgia McBride

Photos by Michael Brosilow




Keith Kupferer (Eddie), Nate Santana (Casey), Leslie Ann Sheppard (Jo), Sean Blake (Miss Tracy Mills), Jeff Kurysz (Rexy, Jason), Raymond K. Cleveland (understudy, Tracy), Michael Manocchio (understudy Rexy, Jason), Billy Minshall (understudy, Eddie), Colin Morgan (understudy, Casey), Charlita Williams (understudy, Jo).

behind the scenes

Lauren Shouse (director), Richard and Jacqueline Penrod (set design), Rachel Laritz (costume design), JR Lederle (lighting design), Kevin O’Donnell (sound design, original music), Chris Carter (choreographer), Lynn Baber (casting director), Rita Vreeland (stage manager), Kristen Osborn, Matthew Stein (dramaturgs), Abigail Boucher, Max Covill (assistant directors), Penny Lane Studios (wigs), Alex Benjamin (makeup consultant), BJ Jones (artistic director), Timothy J. Evans (executive director), Bronte DeShong (properties master), Katy Garcia (production assistant) Stephanie Taylor (interim costume supervisor), Kristin Ginther (second wardrobe), Selma Muminovic (spotlight operator), Michael Brosilow (photos)


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Category: 2017 Reviews, Catey Sullivan, Comedy, North Shore Center for the Arts, Northlight Theatre, Video, YouTube

Comments (0)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

There are no comments yet. Why not be the first to speak your mind.

Comments are closed.